In the FS1 postgame show after the Blue Jays’ 13-4 win, Yankees legend Derek Jeter asked Guerrero the question everyone was thinking. “The question I have for you, man,” Jeter began, via Instagram. “In the history of the sport, there has been one cycle in the postseason. How come you stopped at second base, man?”

The Toronto Blue Jays are focused on their American League Championship Series against the Seattle Mariners, but their rivalry with the New York Yankees is still very much alive. A

After the Blue Jays eliminated the Yankees from the 2025 MLB postseason behind some explosive hitting, Toronto had a slow start the ALCS. That led to Carton accusing the Blue Jays of something that happened in 2017 with the Houston Astros.

The Los Angeles Dodgers are one win away from winning the World Series after beating the New York Yankees to take a 3-0 series lead.